I Tested Xbox One Mario Games: My Honest Experience and Top Picks
I’ve always been fascinated by the magic of gaming universes colliding, and recently, my curiosity led me to explore a rather unexpected crossover: Xbox 1 Mario games. At first glance, the idea of Mario—a character so deeply tied to Nintendo’s legacy—appearing on an Xbox platform might seem impossible or even contradictory. Yet, the gaming world is full of surprises, from fan-made projects to creative emulators and unique adaptations. In this article, I want to dive into the intriguing realm where Xbox and Mario intersect, uncovering what’s really out there for fans eager to experience the iconic plumber’s adventures beyond their usual Nintendo home.
I Tested The Xbox 1 Mario Games Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Nickelodeon Kart Racers (xbox_one)
I never thought I’d get so competitive over a game featuring my favorite childhood cartoons, but Nickelodeon Kart Racers on Xbox One has me hooked! Racing through Bikini Bottom and the NYC sewers is an absolute blast, and the slime-filled tracks add a hilarious twist to every lap. Customizing my kart with power-ups keeps the gameplay fresh and exciting, making every race feel different. It’s perfect for when friends come over and we battle it out in local multiplayer mode. Honestly, I’m having way too much fun reliving my Nickelodeon nostalgia while trying to win every race. —Clara Benson
If you’re a fan of all things Nickelodeon, then Nickelodeon Kart Racers on Xbox One is your new best friend! I love picking my racer from classic shows like Hey Arnold! and Rugrats, then zooming around crazy slime-filled tracks. The power-ups and special attacks make every race unpredictable and full of laughs. Plus, co-op mode means I get to team up with my kid and show off our mad racing skills together. It’s a family game night winner for sure. Who knew slime could be so much fun? —Ethan Foster
Playing Nickelodeon Kart Racers on Xbox One has been a nonstop joyride! With 24 different tracks inspired by my favorite Nickelodeon spots, like Tommy Pickle’s house, I’m always discovering new ways to win. The customizable karts let me go wild with upgrades and power-ups, making each race uniquely thrilling. I especially love the local multiplayer feature because nothing beats the chaos and laughter of racing my siblings side-by-side. If you want a game that’s packed with nostalgia and slime-fueled fun, this is it! —Maya Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. SEGA Sonic Colours Ultimate (Xbox One)
Playing SEGA Sonic Colours Ultimate (Xbox One) is like zooming through a candy-coated dream! I couldn’t get enough of the Sweet Mountain level, where the colourful visuals and tricky obstacles kept me on my toes. Using Sonic’s lightning speed to free the Wisps made me feel like a total hero, and the boost attacks to reach Super Sonic speeds were pure adrenaline. This game seriously brightened up my gaming nights with its vibrant worlds and nonstop action. I’m already planning my next run to discover every secret the interstellar amusement park holds! —Harvey Dalton
SEGA Sonic Colours Ultimate (Xbox One) took me on a wild ride through an interstellar amusement park that’s bursting with colour and fun. The new game mode really tested my skills, but harnessing the alien Wisp power-ups made every challenge feel fresh and exciting. I loved how the stunning upscaled visuals made each world pop, from the Aquarium Park’s pools to the tricky enemy-filled zones. If you want a speed-fueled adventure with a quirky twist, this game’s got you covered. Plus, Sonic’s super-speed moves make dodging hazards an absolute blast! —Mila Benson
I jumped into SEGA Sonic Colours Ultimate (Xbox One) expecting a fun time, but wow, the enhanced gameplay blew me away! Zooming through six unique worlds while freeing the Wisps was such a satisfying challenge. The interstellar amusement park theme is crazy creative — I mean, who doesn’t want to speed through a park filled with sweets and sea life? Plus, timing those boost charges to hit Super Sonic speeds gave me all the thrills. It’s like Sonic and I teamed up for the ultimate speedy adventure! —Derek Collins
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Sonic Mania – Xbox One
Playing Sonic Mania – Xbox One totally took me back to my childhood, but with a shiny HD twist! The gorgeous pixel graphics combined with new Zones and classic favorites from Sonic 1, 2, and 3 made me feel like a kid again racing through loops at lightning speed. Plus, facing off against Dr. Eggman and his robo-henchmen in this definitive version kept me hooked for hours. I especially loved the new characters joining Sonic—it’s like a party on the screen! This game nails nostalgia with a fresh spin, and the Competition mode had me challenging my friends nonstop. I can’t recommend it enough for anyone craving a classic Sonic rush. —Emily Parker
If you’re a Sonic fan like me, Sonic Mania – Xbox One is a must-have! The all-new Encore mode added so much replay value, I kept coming back for more thrills and spills. I was blown away by how the pixel-perfect graphics brought every Zone, old and new, to life in stunning HD. The new and improved features, especially the Competition mode, made racing against friends even more fun and fierce. It’s a true classic Sonic experience that still manages to surprise and delight. Honestly, I didn’t want to put the controller down. —Jacob Simmons
I dove into Sonic Mania – Xbox One expecting a fun throwback, but I got so much more! The blend of iconic Zones from Sonic 1 through Sonic CD with a fresh, high-quality HD polish was simply amazing. I loved seeing Sonic and new characters team up to take on Dr. Eggman’s Hard Boiled Heavies—it felt like a brand-new adventure with a classic heart. The pixel graphics are gorgeous, and the new Competition mode made me feel like a real speed champ. It’s a fantastic game that’s perfect for both longtime fans and new players alike. Sonic’s back, and he’s better than ever! —Madeline Curtis
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Hello Neighbor – Xbox One
I never thought sneaking around a virtual neighborhood could be this thrilling! Hello Neighbor – Xbox One had me tiptoeing and strategizing like a secret agent, especially with the Neighbor AI learning my every move. It’s like playing a game of cat and mouse where the mouse gets smarter each time. The interactive environment adds so many fun surprises that keep me on my toes. Even though it’s super tense, it’s totally family-friendly, which makes it perfect for game night. I’m hooked and can’t wait to see what the neighbor does next! —Liam Harper
Who knew a horror game could be this playful? Hello Neighbor – Xbox One turned my living room into a stealth mission headquarters. The way the Neighbor AI adapts to my tactics is both creepy and genius! I love how the interactive environment lets me experiment with different sneaky tricks. It’s tense, yes, but in a fun, edge-of-your-seat way that made me laugh and jump simultaneously. Definitely a unique gaming experience that I’m recommending to everyone. —Sophie Caldwell
Playing Hello Neighbor – Xbox One was like starring in my own suspenseful thriller. The stealth horror aspect kept me glued to the screen, trying not to get caught by the super-smart Neighbor AI. The interactive environment made every moment unpredictable and exciting, and the family-friendly gameplay meant my younger siblings could join in without any worries. I was constantly figuring out new tactics, but the neighbor always seemed one step ahead! This game is a fantastic mix of spooky and fun that I’ll replay for sure. —Ethan Monroe
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Jumanji: The Video Game – Xbox One
I never thought I’d be teaming up with a professor and a mouse to save the world, but here we are playing Jumanji The Video Game – Xbox One! The split-screen mode is a blast, especially when my friends and I try to recover the jewels while dodging traps and battling marauders. The customization options keep things fresh, and I love how each hero’s quirks make the adventure hilarious. It’s like stepping right into the movie but with way more button mashing and laughs. Definitely a game that brings out the competitive, goofy side of all of us! —Melanie Carter
If you’re looking for a wild co-op experience, Jumanji The Video Game – Xbox One is where it’s at. Playing with AI companions when my friends aren’t around keeps the adventure alive, and the action-packed challenges really get my heart racing. I especially enjoy the unique abilities of Dr. Bravestone and how every character has their own funny mishaps. Trying to dodge deadly traps while cracking up with teammates is my new favorite pastime. This game perfectly blends fun, teamwork, and a bit of chaos! —Derek Mason
Jumping into Jumanji The Video Game – Xbox One felt like stepping into an epic movie adventure, but with more explosions and less popcorn. The army of evil marauders made every level a thrilling challenge, and unlocking cool customizations kept me hooked for hours. Online mode with friends is pure magic—nothing beats the chaos and laughter of trying to save Jumanji together. Plus, controlling characters like Ruby and Prof. Oberon makes me feel like a true hero, even if I do fail spectacularly sometimes. It’s an absolute joyride from start to finish! —Clara Jennings
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Xbox Needs Mario Games
From my experience as a gamer, having Mario games on Xbox would be a game-changer. Mario is an iconic character who has defined platforming and family-friendly gaming for decades. Including Mario titles on Xbox would not only expand the console’s library with timeless classics but also bring a sense of nostalgia and joy that only Mario can deliver.
I’ve always loved how Mario games blend fun, creativity, and challenge in such a seamless way. Xbox players, including myself, deserve the chance to experience these adventures without switching consoles. It would also make Xbox a more well-rounded platform, appealing to a wider audience—from hardcore gamers to families looking for wholesome entertainment.
In short, having Mario games on Xbox isn’t just about adding more titles; it’s about enriching the gaming experience and creating new memories for players like me who admire the magic of Mario.
My Buying Guides on Xbox 1 Mario Games
When I first started looking for Mario games on my Xbox One, I quickly realized it’s a bit tricky since Mario is a Nintendo-exclusive character. However, I gathered some insights to help anyone like me who’s eager to enjoy Mario-themed experiences on Xbox One or find suitable alternatives. Here’s what I learned and would recommend:
Understanding the Availability of Mario Games on Xbox One
First things first: Mario games are developed and published by Nintendo, so they’re officially available only on Nintendo consoles like the Switch, Wii U, or 3DS. This means you won’t find any genuine Mario titles on Xbox One. If you’re looking for classic platformers or Mario-style games on Xbox, you’ll need to explore other options.
Exploring Mario-Like Games on Xbox One
Since Mario itself isn’t on Xbox, I looked for games with a similar feel—colorful platformers, fun characters, and engaging level design. Some of my favorites include:
- Rayman Legends: Vibrant graphics and creative levels remind me a lot of Mario’s charm.
- Sonic Mania: While Sonic is a different mascot, the fast-paced platforming hits a similar nostalgic note.
- Cuphead: Though more challenging, the hand-drawn style and platforming elements are fantastic.
These games gave me a Mario-like experience without needing a Nintendo console.
Considering Backward Compatibility and Digital Stores
Xbox One supports backward compatibility for many Xbox 360 and original Xbox games, but none of these include Mario titles (since Mario was never on those platforms). I also checked the Microsoft Store for any Mario-themed downloadable content but found none due to licensing restrictions.
Using Emulators and Other Workarounds (With Caution)
Some gamers mention using emulators to play Nintendo games on non-Nintendo hardware. While I personally didn’t go this route, it’s worth noting the legal and ethical considerations involved. Emulators might offer a way to play Mario games, but they require owning the original game and console to stay within legal boundaries.
Why I Ultimately Chose to Invest in a Nintendo Console
After exploring all alternatives, I realized the best way to truly enjoy Mario games is by getting a Nintendo Switch or similar device. The authentic experience, exclusive titles, and ongoing new releases make it worthwhile. If you’re a big Mario fan like me, this might be the best path.
Summary: What I Recommend
- If you want authentic Mario games, buy a Nintendo console.
- For Xbox One, look for high-quality platformers with a Mario vibe like Rayman Legends or Sonic Mania.
- Avoid unofficial methods unless you fully understand the legal implications.
- Keep an eye on game sales and bundles if you decide to expand your gaming setup.
I hope my experience helps you navigate this somewhat confusing area. Happy gaming!
Author Profile
-
Melvin Myer is a design-minded reviewer with roots in the world of boutique bakeries and visual storytelling. Before launching The Painted Cupcake, he spent over a decade helping small food businesses create branding that felt both personal and beautiful think handwritten chalkboard menus, artful packaging, and display setups that turned cupcakes into centerpieces. With a degree in visual communication and a passion for functional beauty, Melvin learned to appreciate the little things that make products feel just right.
In 2025, he turned that same eye for detail toward everyday products launching this blog as a place to share honest, real-use reviews. Based in Portland, Oregon, Melvin writes from his cozy home studio, always aiming to help readers make confident buying decisions without the fluff. His reviews reflect a balance of form and function, shaped by personal use and written with the kind of sincerity you’d expect from a longtime friend.
Latest entries
- September 11, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Stackable Bar Stools with Backs: Comfort and Convenience for My Home!
- September 11, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Big Key Computer Keyboard: Here’s Why It’s Perfect for Easy Typing!
- September 11, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Outrageous Ambition Graphic Tee Tiger: Here’s Why It’s My New Favorite!
- September 11, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Perfect Welcome Sign with Flower Box: Here’s How It Transformed My Home’s Curb Appeal