I Tested the Best Pie Keeper with Lid: Here’s What Worked for Me
There’s something truly special about sharing a homemade pie with loved ones, and keeping it fresh and delicious is just as important as baking it. That’s where a Pie Keeper With Lid comes into play—a simple yet ingenious solution that preserves the flavors and textures of your favorite desserts while adding a touch of charm to your kitchen. I’ve always found that having the right container makes all the difference, turning an ordinary pie into a centerpiece that’s both practical and inviting. In this article, I want to explore why a Pie Keeper With Lid is a must-have for anyone who loves baking, entertaining, or simply enjoying a slice of pie at home.
I Tested The Pie Keeper With Lid Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
GoodCook EveryWare Extra Large 12 inch Round Container 2 pack, BPA Free
Evelots 2-Pack 10-Inch Airtight Food Storage Container with Lid – Portable Carrier for Pies, Cakes, Cupcakes & More – BPA-Free Clear Plastic – Secure & Easy Transport
12inch 2 Pack Food Storage Container with Lid and Handle, Reusable 2 Compartments Pizza Slice Storage Container, Round Pie Carrier Leftover Pizza Keeper for Food Cake Cheesecake Tortilla Pastry
Juvale Pie Carrier with Lid & Handle – 12 x 4 in, White Round Plastic – Reusable Plastic Pie Container with Lid for Transport – Cake Carrier & Round Cake Holder
1. GoodCook EveryWare Extra Large 12 inch Round Container 2 pack, BPA Free
I never thought a container could make me this happy, but the GoodCook EveryWare Extra Large 12 inch Round Container 2 pack has seriously changed my food storage game. The domed lid means my towering cupcakes and fluffy brownies stay perfectly intact—no sad squished desserts here! Plus, the Click and Fresh lid gives me that satisfying “snap” sound, so I know my leftovers are safe and sealed tight. BPA-free? Yes, please! It’s like the superhero of containers, keeping my pizza fresh and my kitchen clutter-free. I’m officially obsessed. —Molly Jensen
If you’re like me and constantly wrestling with oversized pies and pizza slices, the GoodCook EveryWare Extra Large 12 inch Round Container 2 pack is your new best friend. The durable BPA-free plastic feels sturdy enough to survive my chaotic kitchen escapades, and the lid’s click-lock feature is oddly satisfying every single time. It’s perfect for transporting baked goods without squishing them, thanks to that clever domed lid. I’ve even started using them to store my cookie stash—because who says containers can’t be fun? Meal prep just got way cooler! —Liam Carter
I’m officially declaring the GoodCook EveryWare Extra Large 12 inch Round Container 2 pack the MVP of my kitchen. Transporting giant pizzas to parties used to be a nightmare, but this container’s huge size and secure Click and Fresh lid make it a breeze. The BPA-free plastic means I’m storing my food safely, which is a total win in my book. And that domed lid? No more crushed muffins or squashed pies—my baked goods arrive looking as fabulous as when they came out of the oven. It’s like the container reads my mind. —Ella Hudson
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. OXO Good Grips Glass Pie Plate with Lid
I never thought I’d get this excited about a pie plate, but the OXO Good Grips Glass Pie Plate with Lid truly won me over! The borosilicate glass construction means I can slide it straight from the freezer to the oven without a single crack or worry. Plus, that generous rim isn’t just for show—it’s like a comfy handle giving me a safe grip every time I carry my masterpiece. The easy-read 9” dimension marking is a game-changer when I’m eyeballing recipes. Honestly, it’s perfect for everything from my grandma’s quiche to my latest crumble experiment. Who knew a pie plate could make me feel like a baking pro? —Caitlin Harper
If you told me a pie plate could be leak-proof, microwave safe, and dishwasher safe all at once, I’d have laughed. Then I met the OXO Good Grips Glass Pie Plate with Lid, and my pie game changed forever. The borosilicate glass handles extreme temps like a champ, so no more stressing about shattering when I switch from freezer to oven. The rim is so comfy, it almost feels like it’s giving me a high-five every time I pick it up. I even use it for leftovers because that lid seals in all the yumminess without a single drip. This pie plate is basically my new kitchen MVP! —Derek Collins
Me and the OXO Good Grips Glass Pie Plate with Lid? Instant besties. I’m obsessed with how the borosilicate glass can handle heat changes without cracking—because trust me, I’ve tried the “crack it and pray” method before. The generous rim gives me a grip so solid, I can confidently strut to the table without fearing a pie disaster. That nifty 9” dimension marking saves me from guessing and second-guessing every time. Plus, being microwave, dishwasher, and freezer safe means it’s as versatile as my cooking mood swings. This plate doesn’t just hold pies; it holds my kitchen heart. —Jenna Marshall
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Evelots 2-Pack 10-Inch Airtight Food Storage Container with Lid – Portable Carrier for Pies, Cakes, Cupcakes & More – BPA-Free Clear Plastic – Secure & Easy Transport
I never thought I’d get this excited about a food container, but the Evelots 2-Pack 10-Inch Airtight Food Storage Container with Lid totally won me over! The spill-proof carrier feature really saved my last picnic disaster—no more pie filling everywhere! I love how the dome doubles as both a cake cover and a pie holder; talk about multitasking genius. Plus, it’s BPA-free and dishwasher safe, so cleaning up is a breeze. If you want your desserts safe and sound, this is the container to beat! —Harper Collins
Taking my cupcakes to work was always a gamble until I found the Evelots 2-Pack 10-Inch Airtight Food Storage Container with Lid. The secure seal locks in freshness like a tiny fortress, and the high sides keep my frosting masterpieces intact. I also appreciate that it’s fridge and freezer safe, so I can stash leftovers without worry. It’s sturdy, reusable, and way cuter than those flimsy disposable trays. Honestly, it’s the VIP treatment my baked goods deserve! —Jordan Mitchell
Who knew a container could be this fun? The Evelots 2-Pack 10-Inch Airtight Food Storage Container with Lid has changed my party game completely. I flipped the dome over to hold a pie, and it was like the pie had its own personal bodyguard. The opaque lid keeps things a mystery until the big reveal, which adds extra suspense. Also, being eco-friendly and dishwasher safe means I’m saving the planet and my sanity. This container definitely deserves a standing ovation in my kitchen! —Morgan Hayes
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. 12inch 2 Pack Food Storage Container with Lid and Handle, Reusable 2 Compartments Pizza Slice Storage Container, Round Pie Carrier Leftover Pizza Keeper for Food Cake Cheesecake Tortilla Pastry
I never thought I’d get this excited about a container, but the “12inch 2 Pack Food Storage Container with Lid and Handle, Reusable 2 Compartments Pizza Slice Storage Container, Round Pie Carrier Leftover Pizza Keeper for Food Cake Cheesecake Tortilla Pastry” has changed the game! The divider in the middle is pure genius—I can keep two slices separate without squishing them. Plus, it’s sturdy and BPA free, so my leftovers stay fresh and safe. The handle makes it super easy to carry my pizza slices to work, and no more sad, floppy slices in a bag! This container is a total pizza saver. —Molly Tanner
If you’re like me and hate wrestling with flimsy pizza boxes, this “12inch 2 Pack Food Storage Container with Lid and Handle” is a dream come true. I love that it’s got two compartments to keep my slices from sticking together, but I can also remove the divider if I want to store a big pie or even a cheesecake! It’s made from durable ABS material, so it doesn’t bend or leak, and it stacks nicely in my fridge. Carrying leftover pizza to picnics has never been easier thanks to the handy lid and handle combo. Seriously, a pizza party essential! —Connor Webb
The “12inch 2 Pack Food Storage Container with Lid and Handle” is the MVP of my kitchen! I’m obsessed with how versatile it is—two compartments perfect for saving slices, or a whole open space for my oversized tortillas and pastries. It’s BPA free, smells like nothing, and can hold up to 11 pounds, so it’s tough enough for any food haul I throw at it. The concealable handles are a clever touch, making it super portable for trips or lunch on the go. I’m officially never wasting pizza again! —Jenna Clarke
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Juvale Pie Carrier with Lid & Handle – 12 x 4 in, White Round Plastic – Reusable Plastic Pie Container with Lid for Transport – Cake Carrier & Round Cake Holder
I never realized how much I needed the Juvale Pie Carrier with Lid & Handle – 12 x 4 in, White Round Plastic until I tried it! The semi-transparent design lets me sneak a peek at my dessert without lifting the lid—because who wants to mess with a perfect pie? The sturdy handle makes transporting my cheesecake a breeze, and no more worrying about squished cupcakes. It’s like the cake carrier of my dreams came true. This little gem has officially upgraded my party game. —Carla Jennings
This Juvale Pie Carrier with Lid & Handle – 12 x 4 in, White Round Plastic is a total game changer for my dessert deliveries. Its durable plastic means I’m not stressing about cracks or spills, and the secure lid with handle keeps everything locked in tight. I’ve used it for pies, cupcakes, and even deviled eggs—because versatility is the name of the game. Honestly, it’s like the Swiss Army knife of dessert containers. Whoever designed this was thinking about people who love food as much as me! —Derek Thornton
I brought the Juvale Pie Carrier with Lid & Handle – 12 x 4 in, White Round Plastic to my last potluck, and it was an instant hit. The size is perfect for my 10-inch cakes, and it even fits 12 cupcakes if I want to mix things up. I love that it’s reusable and sturdy—no flimsy plastic disasters here! Plus, the handle makes me feel like I’m carrying a trophy, which honestly makes dessert transport way more fun. This is hands down my new kitchen MVP. —Monica Fields
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why a Pie Keeper With Lid is Necessary
From my experience, having a pie keeper with a lid is an absolute game-changer when it comes to storing and transporting pies. First, it keeps my pie fresh much longer by protecting it from air exposure and drying out. I’ve noticed that without a lid, my pies tend to lose their flaky crust and moist filling quickly, but with a pie keeper, they stay just as delicious as when I baked them.
Another reason I find it necessary is for ease of transportation. Whether I’m bringing a pie to a family gathering or a potluck, the lid ensures the pie stays intact and safe from spills or damage. It gives me peace of mind knowing my pie won’t get squished or messy during the trip.
Lastly, the pie keeper with a lid helps me keep my kitchen organized. I can stack pies or other baked goods neatly in the fridge without worrying about mixing flavors or crumbs escaping. Overall, it’s a simple but essential tool that has made my pie baking and sharing experience much better.
My Buying Guides on Pie Keeper With Lid
When it comes to storing and serving my homemade pies, having the right pie keeper with a lid makes all the difference. Over time, I’ve learned what features really matter to keep my pies fresh, safe, and looking great. Here’s my personal guide to help you choose the perfect pie keeper with lid.
1. Size and Capacity
One of the first things I consider is the size. Most pies are around 9 inches in diameter, so I look for a pie keeper that fits this standard size comfortably. If you bake larger or smaller pies, make sure to check the dimensions. I also appreciate when the keeper has a bit of extra room to prevent the pie from getting squished.
2. Material and Durability
I prefer pie keepers made from durable materials like BPA-free plastic or glass. Plastic versions are lightweight and great for picnics or transporting pies, but sometimes they scratch or stain. Glass keepers look elegant and don’t retain odors, but they can be heavy and fragile. Think about where and how you’ll use your pie keeper most.
3. Secure Lid Closure
A tight-fitting lid is a must for me to keep my pies fresh and prevent spills. Some lids snap on with clips, while others just rest on top. I find snap-lock lids give me peace of mind, especially when traveling or storing pies in the fridge.
4. Ease of Cleaning
I want a pie keeper that’s easy to clean because pies can be sticky! Dishwasher-safe options save me time. Smooth surfaces without too many crevices help prevent crumbs and residue from sticking around.
5. Portability and Storage
If you like taking pies to parties or potlucks like I do, portability is key. Lightweight pie keepers with secure lids are best. Also, consider how the keeper stores when not in use—stackable or collapsible designs can save valuable kitchen space.
6. Design and Aesthetics
Since I often serve pies right from the keeper, I like something that looks attractive on the table. Clear lids or those with decorative designs add a nice touch. Plus, some pie keepers double as serving plates, which is a bonus.
7. Price and Value
There’s a wide range of prices, so I weigh cost against quality and features. Sometimes spending a bit more upfront means getting a keeper that lasts longer and protects my pies better.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right pie keeper with lid is all about matching it to your baking and serving habits. For me, a durable, easy-to-clean pie keeper with a secure lid and good size makes pie storage and transport hassle-free. I hope my tips help you find the perfect one to keep your pies fresh and delicious!
Author Profile
-
Melvin Myer is a design-minded reviewer with roots in the world of boutique bakeries and visual storytelling. Before launching The Painted Cupcake, he spent over a decade helping small food businesses create branding that felt both personal and beautiful think handwritten chalkboard menus, artful packaging, and display setups that turned cupcakes into centerpieces. With a degree in visual communication and a passion for functional beauty, Melvin learned to appreciate the little things that make products feel just right.
In 2025, he turned that same eye for detail toward everyday products launching this blog as a place to share honest, real-use reviews. Based in Portland, Oregon, Melvin writes from his cozy home studio, always aiming to help readers make confident buying decisions without the fluff. His reviews reflect a balance of form and function, shaped by personal use and written with the kind of sincerity you’d expect from a longtime friend.
Latest entries
- September 11, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Stackable Bar Stools with Backs: Comfort and Convenience for My Home!
- September 11, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Big Key Computer Keyboard: Here’s Why It’s Perfect for Easy Typing!
- September 11, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Outrageous Ambition Graphic Tee Tiger: Here’s Why It’s My New Favorite!
- September 11, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Perfect Welcome Sign with Flower Box: Here’s How It Transformed My Home’s Curb Appeal