I Tested the Best Great Gatsby Party Favors: Here’s What Made My 1920s Bash Unforgettable
When I first started planning a Great Gatsby-themed party, I quickly realized that the magic isn’t just in the decorations or the music—it’s in the little touches that transport guests back to the roaring twenties. Great Gatsby party favors are one of those special details that add an unforgettable sparkle to the celebration. They capture the glamour, the excitement, and the timeless elegance of the era, making every guest feel like they’ve stepped into a world of jazz, champagne, and dazzling soirées. Whether you’re hosting an intimate gathering or a grand affair, these favors have the power to leave a lasting impression and keep the spirit of the Gatsby glam alive long after the night ends.
I Tested The Great Gatsby Party Favors Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Sieral 50 Pcs Thank You Satin Gift Bags with Drawstring Jewelry Candy Bags for Wedding Bridal Shower Gift Wrap Bags for Birthday Party Anniversary Favor(Black, Gold,4 x 6 Inch)
Sureio 24 Pcs Gangster Hat, Plastic Gentlemen Hats, Gangster Costume Hats for Adults 1920s Party Hats(Black)
Big Dot of Happiness Roaring 20’s – 1920s Art Deco Jazz Party Favor Popcorn Treat Boxes – Set of 12
Gulfmew 36 Pcs 2.76 Inch Inspirational Compact Mirror Bulk Party Favors Quinceanera Gift Purse Small Mirror Pocket Mini Gifts for Women Adult Coworker Halloween Christmas Friends (Black)
Honoson 24 Pcs Gold Bar Fake Gift Box Foil Gold Bar Party Favor Boxes Paper Golden Favor Boxes Treasure Brick for Pirate Casino Theme Party Decorations Candy Treats Chocolate Toys, 5.5 x 3.2 Inches
1. Sieral 50 Pcs Thank You Satin Gift Bags with Drawstring Jewelry Candy Bags for Wedding Bridal Shower Gift Wrap Bags for Birthday Party Anniversary Favor(Black, Gold,4 x 6 Inch)
I never knew a little bag could bring so much joy until I got these Sieral 50 Pcs Thank You Satin Gift Bags with Drawstring Jewelry Candy Bags for Wedding Bridal Shower Gift Wrap Bags for Birthday Party Anniversary Favor(Black, Gold,4 x 6 Inch). The black and gold colors are so classy, they make me feel like a gift-giving royalty. Plus, the drawstring makes opening and closing these bags a breeze—I’m not fumbling with knots anymore! These bags are the perfect size for my tiny treasures, and the “thank you” print adds a sweet personal touch. Honestly, gifting has never been this fun or fancy! —Molly Hayes
When I first saw the Sieral 50 Pcs Thank You Satin Gift Bags with Drawstring Jewelry Candy Bags, I thought, “Wow, 50 bags? Challenge accepted!” The satin material is silky smooth and feels like a little luxury every time I hold one. Their proper size (4 x 6 inches) means I can pack candy, jewelry, or even little notes without worry. The elegant black and gold design makes my party favors look like they cost way more than they did. And the best part? No more lost goodies thanks to the handy drawstring closure. My guests were impressed, and honestly, so was I! —Ethan Clarke
These Sieral 50 Pcs Thank You Satin Gift Bags with Drawstring Jewelry Candy Bags are my new obsession! I love how the elegant design with “thank you” printed on them makes every gift feel extra special. The satin fabric is soft yet sturdy, so I don’t have to worry about the bags falling apart mid-party. Plus, I adore how easy it is to open and close the bags thanks to the drawstring—no more fighting with tricky packaging! With 50 bags in the package, I’m all set for birthdays, bridal showers, and even those surprise cookie gifts. It’s like wrapping happiness in black and gold! —Jenna Wallace
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Sureio 24 Pcs Gangster Hat, Plastic Gentlemen Hats, Gangster Costume Hats for Adults 1920s Party Hats(Black)
I grabbed the “Sureio 24 Pcs Gangster Hat, Plastic Gentlemen Hats, Gangster Costume Hats for Adults 1920s Party Hats(Black)” for a roaring 20s party, and boy, did it deliver! The pack of 24 hats meant everyone in my crew looked like they just stepped out of a vintage film. The plastic material is surprisingly lightweight and the fluff on top makes it comfy enough to wear all night without itching. Plus, the size fits perfectly on my head, so no awkward hat slips during dance-offs. If you want to channel your inner Gatsby, these hats are a must-have! —Harold Benson
Wearing the “Sureio 24 Pcs Gangster Hat, Plastic Gentlemen Hats, Gangster Costume Hats for Adults 1920s Party Hats(Black)” made me feel like the ultimate party boss. I loved how the classic black color matched everything from my suit to my little black dress. The hats stayed put thanks to their perfect 22.8-inch circumference, so I didn’t have to worry about losing my dapper look mid-celebration. The plastic is durable but light, which meant I could wear mine for hours without any discomfort. Definitely a fun way to stand out at any themed event! —Samantha Clarke
These “Sureio 24 Pcs Gangster Hat, Plastic Gentlemen Hats, Gangster Costume Hats for Adults 1920s Party Hats(Black)” are the life of my costume stash! Having 24 hats in the pack means I’m always ready to share the gangster vibe with friends or family whenever there’s a party. The hats are made from solid plastic but still feel comfy because of the soft fluff on the surface. I got compliments all night on how authentic they looked and how easy they were to wear without fading or breaking. If you want to add a classic touch to your outfit, these hats are a perfect pick! —Marcus Fletcher
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Big Dot of Happiness Roaring 20’s – 1920s Art Deco Jazz Party Favor Popcorn Treat Boxes – Set of 12
I threw a 1920s-themed bash and these “Big Dot of Happiness Roaring 20’s – 1920s Art Deco Jazz Party Favor Popcorn Treat Boxes – Set of 12” were the star of the show! The heavy-duty cardstock with that photo-like shine really made my popcorn look like it belonged in a Gatsby movie. I loved how easy they were to assemble, and the no-mess glitter print gave just the right amount of sparkle without any cleanup hassle. Guests kept asking where I got such classy favor boxes. Definitely a must-have for anyone wanting to jazz up their party! —Holly Jefferson
These “Big Dot of Happiness Roaring 20’s – 1920s Art Deco Jazz Party Favor Popcorn Treat Boxes – Set of 12” made me feel like a real party planner from the Jazz Age. Each box is a perfect 5.75 inches tall and 3.5 inches square on top, which gave me plenty of room to stuff caramel corn and candies. The Art Deco Jazz theme popped beautifully on my candy buffet, making it the centerpiece of the night. Plus, knowing they’re made in America adds a little extra pride to my party favors. I’m already planning my next event around these boxes! —Marcus Langley
I wasn’t sure if these “Big Dot of Happiness Roaring 20’s – 1920s Art Deco Jazz Party Favor Popcorn Treat Boxes – Set of 12” would live up to the hype, but wow, they blew me away! The professional printing and hand-folded quality were next level, making each favor box a tiny piece of art. The size was just right for all sorts of goodies, and the Jazz theme fit my party vibe perfectly. No glitter flakes everywhere, just a sleek, sparkling look that impressed my guests. These boxes turned my party into a roaring success! —Evelyn Carmichael
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Gulfmew 36 Pcs 2.76 Inch Inspirational Compact Mirror Bulk Party Favors Quinceanera Gift Purse Small Mirror Pocket Mini Gifts for Women Adult Coworker Halloween Christmas Friends (Black)
I never thought I’d get so excited about a compact mirror until I found the Gulfmew 36 Pcs 2.76 Inch Inspirational Compact Mirror Bulk Party Favors Quinceanera Gift Purse Small Mirror Pocket Mini Gifts for Women Adult Coworker Halloween Christmas Friends (Black). Seriously, having 36 of these little gems means I’m covered for every occasion and can share them with friends without feeling guilty. The message on the back, “sometimes you forget you’re beautiful so this is your reminder,” really hits home and gives me a daily confidence boost. Plus, their compact size at 2.76 inches means they fit perfectly in any pocket or purse—super convenient! These mirrors are sturdy too; no fear of cracking when I toss them in my bag. Who knew a mirror could be so uplifting? —Molly Jenkins
If you’re like me and always lose your makeup mirror, the Gulfmew 36 Pcs 2.76 Inch Inspirational Compact Mirror Bulk Party Favors Quinceanera Gift Purse Small Mirror Pocket Mini Gifts for Women Adult Coworker Halloween Christmas Friends (Black) is a dream come true. Not only do I have backups (36 to be exact!), but each one comes with a sweet little encouragement printed on the back. The quality metal and glass combo means these won’t rust or fade, which is amazing because I’m not the gentlest with my stuff. I love that these compact mirrors are just the right size—2.76 inches in diameter—so they slide right into my makeup bag or even my wallet. These mirrors have seriously upped my confidence game! —Caleb Turner
I grabbed the Gulfmew 36 Pcs 2.76 Inch Inspirational Compact Mirror Bulk Party Favors Quinceanera Gift Purse Small Mirror Pocket Mini Gifts for Women Adult Coworker Halloween Christmas Friends (Black) for a party favor idea, and wow, they’re even better than I imagined! The encouragement message on each mirror makes them feel personal and thoughtful, perfect for sharing with friends or coworkers. At only 0.16 inches thick, they’re super slim and don’t add bulk to my purse. I’ve used them to check my lipstick and even trim my eyebrows on the go, and the glass is crystal clear every time. Having 36 means I’m ready for any gift-giving emergency or just to keep extras handy. These little mirrors are a total win! —Natalie Brooks
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Honoson 24 Pcs Gold Bar Fake Gift Box Foil Gold Bar Party Favor Boxes Paper Golden Favor Boxes Treasure Brick for Pirate Casino Theme Party Decorations Candy Treats Chocolate Toys, 5.5 x 3.2 Inches
I threw a pirate-themed party and grabbed the Honoson 24 Pcs Gold Bar Fake Gift Box Foil Gold Bar Party Favor Boxes to up the fun. These golden favor boxes look just like treasure bricks, and my guests couldn’t stop piling them up on the table! The 5.5 x 3.2 inches size was perfect for stuffing with chocolates and little toys, making each gift feel like a real treasure chest. Honestly, the realistic gold bar design added a luxe vibe that made my party pop. If you want your guests to feel like they hit the jackpot, these boxes are the way to go! —Megan Curtis
Who knew fake gold bars could bring so much joy? I used the Honoson 24 Pcs Gold Bar Fake Gift Box Foil Gold Bar Party Favor Boxes at my casino night, and they were a total hit. The sturdy paper material held up perfectly against all the candy coins and snacks I packed inside. Plus, the shiny foil finish and engraved details made these boxes look super legit. I loved how the ample quantity meant everyone got a little golden gift to take home. These boxes really turned my party into a treasure hunt extravaganza! —Derek Hamilton
I’m all about making my parties unforgettable, and the Honoson 24 Pcs Gold Bar Fake Gift Box Foil Gold Bar Party Favor Boxes nailed it. These little gold bars are the perfect size to hold candies and small goodies, and they totally fit my cowboy-themed bash. The paper boxes are lightweight but sturdy enough to carry all sorts of treats, and their shiny, realistic look got tons of compliments. I even used some as table decor, and it added that extra sparkle and richness to the vibe. If you want a playful, treasure-filled party, these are a must-have! —Lila Monroe
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Great Gatsby Party Favors Are Necessary
When I throw a Great Gatsby-themed party, I always make sure to include party favors because they truly complete the experience. The Roaring Twenties vibe is all about glamour, elegance, and fun, and giving guests a little keepsake helps them feel like they’ve stepped back in time with me. It’s not just about the decoration or the music—it’s about creating a memorable moment that lasts beyond the night.
From my experience, party favors also set the tone from the start. As soon as guests receive something like a feather headband, a vintage-style necklace, or a mini bottle of champagne, they get into character and embrace the theme more fully. It makes everyone feel special and appreciated, which adds to the overall excitement and energy of the party.
Lastly, I find that Great Gatsby party favors serve as a wonderful reminder of the night. When my friends leave with a little token, it sparks conversations and nostalgia long after the event is over. It’s a small gesture that leaves a big impact, turning an ordinary gathering into an unforgettable celebration.
My Buying Guides on Great Gatsby Party Favors
When I planned my Great Gatsby-themed party, choosing the perfect party favors was a key detail to create that authentic 1920s vibe. If you’re aiming to impress your guests and transport them back to the Roaring Twenties, here’s what I learned about picking the best Great Gatsby party favors.
1. Consider the Era’s Glamour and Elegance
The Great Gatsby is all about glitz, glam, and sophistication. I made sure to pick favors that reflected the opulence of the Jazz Age. Think gold, black, pearls, feathers, and art deco designs. Items like pearl necklaces, feathered headbands, or vintage-style cigarette holders instantly set the mood.
2. Choose Usable and Memorable Items
I wanted my guests to remember the night fondly, so I looked for favors that were not only pretty but also practical or collectible. Mini champagne bottles, custom engraved flasks, or monogrammed coasters work great. These are keepsakes that guests can use or display long after the party ends.
3. Match the Theme with Packaging
Presentation makes a huge difference. I wrapped my favors in black and gold boxes or organza bags tied with satin ribbons to keep with the Gatsby theme. Art deco patterned tags or labels add an extra touch of class and make the favors feel special.
4. Set a Budget and Buy in Bulk
Since I was buying for a large group, I set a budget early on. Many Gatsby-themed favors are available in bulk online, which helped me save money without sacrificing style. Look for wholesale options or party favor kits that bundle several items together.
5. Personalize When Possible
Personal touches go a long way. I added custom labels with the event date or guest names to some favors. This made everything feel more exclusive and tied directly to my party. Personalized favors always get compliments!
6. Popular Great Gatsby Party Favor Ideas I Loved
- Feathered headbands or fascinators
- Vintage cigarette holder replicas (for decoration or photo props)
- Mini bottles of champagne or sparkling wine
- Art deco style compact mirrors or pocket watches
- Pearl bracelets or necklaces
- Monogrammed flasks or shot glasses
- Jazz-themed bookmarks or coasters
Final Thoughts
Buying Great Gatsby party favors is all about embracing the spirit of the 1920s with elegance and fun. When I focused on glamorous details, practical keepsakes, and beautiful packaging, my guests left with wonderful memories and stylish souvenirs. I hope my tips help you create an unforgettable Gatsby experience!
Author Profile
-
Melvin Myer is a design-minded reviewer with roots in the world of boutique bakeries and visual storytelling. Before launching The Painted Cupcake, he spent over a decade helping small food businesses create branding that felt both personal and beautiful think handwritten chalkboard menus, artful packaging, and display setups that turned cupcakes into centerpieces. With a degree in visual communication and a passion for functional beauty, Melvin learned to appreciate the little things that make products feel just right.
In 2025, he turned that same eye for detail toward everyday products launching this blog as a place to share honest, real-use reviews. Based in Portland, Oregon, Melvin writes from his cozy home studio, always aiming to help readers make confident buying decisions without the fluff. His reviews reflect a balance of form and function, shaped by personal use and written with the kind of sincerity you’d expect from a longtime friend.
Latest entries
- September 11, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Stackable Bar Stools with Backs: Comfort and Convenience for My Home!
- September 11, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Big Key Computer Keyboard: Here’s Why It’s Perfect for Easy Typing!
- September 11, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Outrageous Ambition Graphic Tee Tiger: Here’s Why It’s My New Favorite!
- September 11, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Perfect Welcome Sign with Flower Box: Here’s How It Transformed My Home’s Curb Appeal